Made in 1860, the above ring from Olivia Collings Antiques has pizzazz—although it predates the word. Nothing is quite as romantic as vintage jewelry, the idea that the ring you're twirling around your figure once belonged to some glamorous figure. Its angular shape is eye-catching, with a worn-in gold band and the unusual arrangement of its 36 small diamonds. Not your standard Tiffany's solitary. Priced at $3,135 and available at Barneys.
For more Most Wanted, click here.